At the end of the rainbow: where next for the LGBTI refugee? | S Chelvan
- 24 January 2014
Listen to the 22 January seminar by S Chelvan (No5 Chambers), part of the Hilary term 2014 Public Seminar Series
Following the heralded 2010 landmark judgment of the UK Supreme Court in HJ (Iran) and HT (Cameroon), the LGBTI refugee has faced a culture of disbelief, which has led in some instances to filming, or photographing of sexual acts, to ‘prove’ identity. Analysing his DSSH (Difference, Stigma, Shame and Harm) model, endorsed by UNHCR, and adopted by both New Zealand and Sweden, Mr Chelvan tackles directly the main hurdle facing LGBTI refugees, ie proving refugee status based on actual, or perceived sexual or gender identity, within a humane investigatory framework.
Mr Chelvan then shifts the focus of status determination away from the victim, to the persecutor in the country of origin, as this provides the source of the refugee claim. Through the prism of identification of the victim due to their lack of conformity with a heteronormative stereotype, this leads to persecution, and motivates migration. The Supreme Court in providing guidelines – which still enable claims to fail on the basis of discretion – fails to engage with this point, highlighting the urgent need to focus on perception as the primary factor in LGBTI refugee claims.
About the speaker
S Chelvan is a Barrister at No5 Chambers and a PhD in Law Candidate at King’s College London. Chelvan has an international reputation as an expert in asylum claims based on sexual or gender identity. Chambers & Partners UK and Legal 500 rank him as a leading immigration junior.