Cookies on this site

Catherine Briddick, Refugee Studies Centre Director, outlines the key themes of her book Violence against Women and Regimes of Exception (OUP, 2025). Evaluating six legal regimes, the book reveals the devastating impact of rules that increase women’s vulnerability to violence, deny them protection from it, and render many victims destitute and at risk of deportation.

A woman holds a girls hand in a train station © Getty images/Unsplash +

For eight years, I worked for a feminist not-for-profit organisation that provided women in England and Wales with legal advice. Almost all the women we spoke to had experienced some form of gender-based violence. A significant proportion of them had a migration status in the UK that was not secure. Some had come to the UK to work or to join family members. Others sought protection as refugees. Advising women on both immigration law and violence was, and remains, extremely difficult.

In the UK, as in many other jurisdictions, a person’s migration status determines almost every aspect of its holder’s life. It often makes women dependent, legally and practically, on a person who is violent towards them. It also influences the behaviour of perpetrators. Women who seek to end a relationship, or live independently of an abuser, may be threatened with immigration detention and deportation. Partners are not alone in being granted a permission to remain that enforces their dependency or restricts their rights. Domestic workers are rendered dependent-in-practice for their migration status on their employer. Both statuses, those of partner and domestic worker, increase their holder’s vulnerability to violence. At the same time, restrictions that apply to them specifically, and other migrants generally, prevent those who are subject to violence from escaping from it. To complicate matters even more, legal routes that appear to offer security of residence to women who have experienced gender-based violence seldom provide this remedy. Applying for such protection, and then being denied it, not only increases women’s vulnerability to violence, it also exposes them to other risks, including destitution.

The two sets of questions I had as a practitioner about situations like these are now reflected in the two parts of the book. Part One examines how migration statuses, like those of partner and domestic worker, are created, distributed, and manipulated. It explores rules that appear to be gender or race neutral, but which actually disadvantage particular groups of people. It also reveals the impact that migration status has on an experience of violence. Here, I make an argument about what would be reparative of the particular disadvantage that migration law creates, one that I draw on in Part Two to analyse rules that appear to offer residence to some migrant victims of gender-based violence. By bringing together distinct responses to violence experienced in the context of migration control, the book outlines a new framework for their evaluation and determines how rights and protection could better be secured.

The book’s analysis begins in the UK and with the European Convention on Human Rights, broadening to connect with European Union (EU) law and the Council of Europe’s Conventions on trafficking and on violence and discrimination against women. Adopting this approach enables me to explore the role and ability of national courts, the European Court of Human Rights, and the Court of Justice of the European Union, to scrutinise differential and discriminatory treatment.

This book was researched and written at a difficult time, legally and otherwise. Significant changes to immigration law have followed the UK’s departure from the EU. These and other developments in relation to the law on violence against women have taken place against the backdrop of the coronavirus pandemic and a populist backlash against migrants’ rights. In the book, I chart and reflect on these changes. As a feminist legal scholar, I also structure the arguments I make around the legal challenges that migrant women have brought to the rules that determine their status. The use of these cases as a narrative device does some justice to the women who shaped each regime. It also focuses attention on women whose experiences of violence continue to be compounded by rules that disadvantage and discriminate against them.

This article was first published in The Antonian in January 2026.

Access  Violence against Women and Regimes of Exception: Undoing Discrimination in Migration Law